Tesions among cosmological datasets

It has been established that 6 parameters can be used to describe most of our universe. This 6 parameters flat Lambda-CDM model outlines the observations on scales larger than (roughly) 100 Mpc, within a precision of 10%. However, as the measurement precision drastically improves, discrepancies among measurements, within 10% but statistically significant, arise. The most notable discrepancy is the Hubble tension. Aside from Hubble tension, there are indeed more tensions, indicating either we mis-interpreted existing measurements or there is new physics beyond the 6 parameters model. A complete evaluation and interpretation of such apparent discrepancies in the data would therefore rest on:

Alternative calibration for standard candle type measurements: Gravitational Wave

Hubble tension is one of the most pronounced tensions - at a statistical significance as high as >5 sigma. One can attribute the mismatch between the CMB based measurement and the supernovae based measurement to the systematics of either (or both) measurement. It is therefore valuable to have alternative probes that rest on a separated set of required presumptions to interpret the data. This would allow for contrasting the incorrect presumption made in the existing measurements, therefore pinning down the root cause of Hubble tension.

With my collaborators, I proposed a method using gravitational wave radiation from neutron star-black hole mergers to measure the expansion in the late time universe. Just as any other standard candle-like methods (supernovae in particular), calibration to standardise the signal strength is one of the most important steps. We showed that it is possible to calibrate with the neutron star mass function empirically constrained by the pulsar-neutron star systems within the Milky Way. Some cautions need to be made in selecting the population of neutron stars for Hubble constant measurement - analogous to biassing towards type-Ia supernovae in traditional standard candle method.

Solving multiple tensions all at once

Email

wing.h.fung [at] durham [dot] ac [dot] uk

Address

OCW223, Ogden Centre for Fundamental Physics West,
Durham University, Stockton Rd, Durham DH1 3LE
UK